Time to Pull the Starting QB? Here Are the Pros and Cons of Making the Move for 5 Teams
The question of whether to stick with the starting quarterback has surfaced across the NFL recently, a clear sign that some teams are struggling and considering a change under center.
Some coaches, like Kellen Moore of the New Orleans Saints, have publicly declared their commitment to their current starter, despite recent struggles. This unwavering support came after Spencer Rattler’s disastrous performance against the Chicago Bears, where he threw three interceptions and lost a fumble in a 26-14 defeat, dropping the Saints’ record to 1-6. However, Moore later stated that the decision is "a week-to-week thing," leaving room for speculation.
Other coaches, such as Aaron Glenn of the New York Jets, are taking a more cautious approach, stating that they need time to evaluate the situation before making a decision. The Jets, currently sitting at 0-7, have seen Justin Fields struggle mightily, averaging fewer than 4 yards per pass attempt in his last two games. This marks the first time a starting quarterback has achieved such a low average in consecutive starts in the past two seasons, highlighting the Jets’ offensive woes and increasing the pressure to find a solution.
It’s worth noting that numerous quarterbacks who were once benched or cast aside by their original teams have found success elsewhere. Daniel Jones of the Indianapolis Colts is a prime example, having revitalized his career after leaving his previous team. Similarly, Baker Mayfield of the Tampa Bay Buccaneers and Sam Darnold of the Seattle Seahawks are currently thriving after being given second chances. These success stories serve as a reminder that a change of scenery can sometimes unlock a quarterback’s potential, and teams should carefully consider the long-term implications before making a hasty decision.
Another crucial factor to consider is the upcoming NFL Draft. Teams with high draft picks will need to assess their current quarterbacks to determine whether to invest valuable draft capital in a replacement. This evaluation process adds another layer of complexity to the decision-making process, as teams must weigh the potential of their current quarterbacks against the allure of acquiring a promising prospect in the draft.
To delve deeper into these quarterback controversies, NFL Nation reporters Rich Cimini (Jets), Ryan McFadden (Raiders), Kevin Seifert (Vikings), Katherine Terrell (Saints), and Josh Weinfuss (Cardinals) provide insights into the specific situations facing each team.
Could Go Either Way
New York Jets (0-7)
- Current starter: Justin Fields
- Key stat: A career-low 32.1 Total QBR, which ranks 31st out of 33 qualified passers.
- Possible replacement: Tyrod Taylor
Why the move might be made: The Jets’ offense has been anemic, failing to score a touchdown in two straight games and managing only seven touchdowns in the past six games, with six of those coming in garbage time. With the team desperate for a win, head coach Aaron Glenn might turn to Taylor, who, despite being turnover-prone, is more willing to push the ball downfield.
Why the Jets might stick with Fields for now: The Jets invested heavily in Fields, giving him a $30 million guarantee on a two-year contract. Despite his struggles, Fields still possesses more upside than Taylor. With the playoffs seemingly out of reach, Glenn might give Fields one more chance to prove himself before making a change.
Long-term implications: The Jets are projected to have the No. 1 pick in the upcoming draft and could potentially select a quarterback. Cutting Fields after the season would result in a significant dead cap charge, adding to the financial burden of already paying Aaron Rodgers, who is no longer on the roster.
Change Might Be Close
Minnesota Vikings (3-3)
- Current starter: Carson Wentz
- Key stat: He is 2-2 as a starter.
- Possible replacement: J.J. McCarthy
Why the move might be made: The Vikings need to get McCarthy back on the field to provide him with the valuable live-game reps he needs for his development. While Wentz has shown some positive attributes, his overall performance has been that of a low-level starter/high-end backup.
Why the Vikings might stick with Wentz for now: McCarthy is still recovering from an ankle sprain, and head coach Kevin O’Connell is hesitant to rush him back before he is fully prepared. With a short week and a road game against the Los Angeles Chargers, it might be difficult for McCarthy to get up to speed in time.
Long-term implications: McCarthy needs to get back on the field after missing significant time due to injuries. The longer he remains sidelined, the less time he will have to establish himself as the team’s long-term quarterback before the end of the season.
Week to Week
New Orleans Saints (1-6)
